Last reviewed: October 2026 · By the SmartCoverage Editorial Team · How we research
Picture two neighbors with the same house and the same storm damage. One waits a month for an adjuster and argues over every line of the estimate. The other has a repair crew booked within a week. They may even pay similar premiums. What separates them is the insurer, and that is what this guide is about.
On customer satisfaction, Amica, Erie and Chubb led J.D. Power’s 2026 home insurance study, with USAA scoring higher still for the military families it serves. On claims, Amica, The Hartford and Chubb came out on top. On price, USAA, Allstate and State Farm were among the cheapest of the large insurers in Insurance.com’s 2026 averages. No company wins on all three, so start with the comparison below.
Sort by price or service, or filter by what you need. Tap a column name to sort.
Price: Insurance.com 2026 average for $300,000 dwelling, $300,000 liability, $1,000 deductible, good credit. Satisfaction: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study (homeowners segment average 644). Claims: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study (average 702). “Above avg.” means J.D. Power reported the insurer above average without publishing its score. “n/a” means no published figure. For guidance only.
What the numbers say, and what they leave out
Home insurance has had a hard few years. Insurance.com’s 2026 national average is $2,872 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage, but the range between states is enormous: from $738 in Hawaii to $8,471 in Florida. Where you live often matters more than which company you pick, which is why a national average for each insurer should be read as a rough guide, not a quote.
Satisfaction scores fell across the industry in 2026. Amica still led homeowners with 680 points, but that was 25 points lower than a year before. Erie (678) and Chubb (676) were close behind, all well above the segment average of 644. One finding stands out: only 55% of homeowners said they completely understood their policy, and that share has barely moved in six years. A quarter said they had received conflicting answers from different sources.
The claims study tells a more encouraging story. Overall claims satisfaction rose 20 points to 702, helped by faster repairs: the average repair took 29.6 days, down 2.8 days, and customers waited 40.7 days for final payment, down 3.4. Amica (773), The Hartford (756) and Chubb (744) led, with Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Erie and Progressive Home also above average.
Who we would quote first
If you or your family served in the military, start with USAA. It had the lowest average price among the large insurers here ($2,260) and scored 741 in J.D. Power’s 2026 study, 97 points above average, although it is not officially ranked because membership is restricted.
If service matters most, get a quote from Amica. It ranked first among eligible insurers in both the satisfaction and the claims studies in 2026; only USAA, which is limited to military families, scored higher on satisfaction. Insurance.com did not publish an average price for it, so compare a real quote against two cheaper names.
If you live in one of Erie’s states, it is worth a quote for its combination of strong satisfaction scores and above-average claims handling, even though its average price ($3,176) was higher than the cheapest national insurers in this data.
If your home is worth well above average, or you have valuable collections, look at Chubb. It specializes in higher-value homes and ranked third in both 2026 studies. Our guide to insurance for high-value homes explains what extra coverage to ask for.
If price comes first, Allstate, State Farm and Travelers were all below the national average in Insurance.com’s data, and all three sell through agents almost everywhere. If you also need car insurance, ask for a bundle price: our guide to home and auto bundle discounts shows how much it can save.
Why the cheapest premium can cost you more
A homeowners policy is judged on the day you claim. Two policies with the same price can pay very differently because of what they cover and how. Before you compare prices, check four things in each quote:
- Replacement cost or actual cash value. Replacement cost pays to rebuild or replace at today’s prices; actual cash value deducts depreciation, which on an older roof can be most of its cost.
- Dwelling coverage amount. It should match the cost to rebuild your home, not its market price. Too little and you pay the difference.
- Separate deductibles for wind, hail or hurricanes, often a percentage of the dwelling amount rather than a fixed dollar figure.
- Exclusions. Standard policies do not cover flood, and most do not cover earthquake. Our guide to what homeowners insurance covers walks through the gaps.
If your insurer raises your rate or will not renew
Many homeowners are shopping not by choice but because their renewal price jumped or their insurer sent a non-renewal notice, especially in states hit by hurricanes, wildfires or hail. If that happens to you, do not wait until the last week.
- Read the notice carefully. It should say why the policy is not being renewed and how much notice you have. Rules on notice periods vary by state.
- Ask what would change the decision. Sometimes a roof inspection, a new roof or removing a hazard such as an old wood stove is enough.
- Get quotes from an independent agent, who can reach regional insurers that are still writing new policies in your area.
- Use your state’s FAIR plan as a last resort. Many states run a FAIR plan, an insurer of last resort for homes that cannot get coverage in the regular market. Coverage is often more limited and prices can be high, so keep looking for a regular policy.
Your state insurance department can tell you which insurers are active in your area and how to file a complaint if you think a decision was unfair.
Discounts worth asking for
Once you have a shortlist, the same company can quote noticeably different prices depending on what you ask for. Mention every one of these that applies: bundling with car insurance, a monitored alarm or water-leak sensors, a new or impact-resistant roof, storm shutters, being claim-free for several years, paying the annual premium in one go, and paperless billing. Raising your deductible lowers the premium too, but only choose an amount you could pay from savings tomorrow.
Check any insurer in ten minutes
Before you sign, look up the company in the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search. It shows how many complaints state regulators received about the insurer’s homeowners policies compared with its size: an index below 1 means fewer complaints than expected. Then ask the agent two questions that rarely appear in brochures: how a typical claim is handled from the first call to the final payment, and whether the company has a direct repair program. In J.D. Power’s data, customers who used one had repairs finished more than two weeks sooner on serious claims.
If you are still choosing between quotes, our walkthrough for finding cheap homeowners insurance by state covers what drives prices where you live.
Sources
- Insurance.com: Average home insurance cost in 2026 (updated September 21, 2026)
- J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study, summary (September 2026)
- USAA: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study result (October 2026)
- Claims Journal: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study (March 2026)
- NAIC Consumer Insurance Search
This guide is for informational purposes only and is not insurance advice. Prices are averages for one home profile and vary widely by state and property. Coverage and availability differ by insurer; read the policy and confirm details with a licensed agent.